Prince Henry of Portugal vs. Zheng He
UPDATE: Tom sent an interesting article that challenges the ideas brought fourth by Gavin Menzies in 1421: The Year China Discovered America (see article information below). Robert Finlay asserts that: "It is impossible to keep track of how many self-confirming assumptions are at work in such citations of alleged evidence. Piling supposition upon supposition, Menzies never considers a question that he does not beg: every argument in 1421 springs from the fallacy of petitio principii. The author’s “trail of evidence” is actually a feedback loop that makes no distinction between premise and proof, conjecture and confirmation, bizarre guess and proven fact."
Journal of World History, Volume 15, 2004
Finlay, Robert, How Not to (Re)Write World History: Gavin Menzies and the Chinese Discovery of America
08_HistoryPodcast.mp3
Links:
Personalities & Problems: Interpretive Essays in World Civilization, Vol II
When China Ruled the Seas: The Treasure Fleet of the Dragon Throne, 1405-1433
Survey Ocean Shores (Hakluyt Society S.)
Henry the Navigator: The Story of a Great Prince and His Times
1421 : The Year China Discovered America (historical facts questionable)
History related podcast:
http://www.historydaily.com
http://www.opaquelucidity.com
http://speakingofhistory.blogspot.com
<< Home